To consider any requests received in accordance with Part 4, Section B, paragraph 29 of the Council’s constitution.
Minutes:
Cllr Clarke informed the Committee that two deputations had been received:
Brenda Allan, Chair of KONP Primary Care Working Group, introduced the first deputation, explaining that there were two main elements to the group’s concerns:
On the issue of PAs, Brenda Allan explained that there were concerns about risks to patient safety as a result of these changes, particularly following the recent death of a patient who had been misdiagnosed by a PA at a medical practice in north London.
On the issue of the sale of GP practices, Brenda Allan explained that, having acquired the practices in 2021, Operose Health had now announced plans to sell the practices to HCRG Care Group on the basis that they were not profitable, despite being paid more per patient than under the previous owners. She said that there had been little public consultation on this issue and proposed that there should be a rigorous procurement exercise and scrutiny of HCRG Care Group, and their owners T20, on their service track record, financial viability, long term commitment and suitability to provide primary care. She described deficiencies in the performance of services previously taken over by HCRG Care Group and concerns about their lack of transparency, which were set out in more detail in the written submission to the Committee. She concluded by expressing a preference for PCNs and GP Federations to run the practices instead.
Brenda Allan then responded to questions from the Committee:
Sarah McDonnell-Davies, Executive Director of Place at the NCL ICB, then responded to the points made by the deputation. She explained that the change of ownership required the approval of the ICB and that this process had also occurred previously following the change from AT Medics to Operose Health and had led to a Judicial Review. The process this time would involve a broader engagement plan than the first time. The ICB had legal levers at their disposal which enabled them to carry out a process of due diligence, overseen by the Primary Care Commissioning Committee, that looked at issues such as financial standing, track record and potential for changes to services. While this process would be thorough, the ICB would not be in a position to reject the proposed changes without operational grounds to do so. The ICB’s main priority was therefore to do as much due diligence as possible and to add safeguards where appropriate. The ICB was also doing what it could to ensure that local providers had ample opportunities to access primary care contracts.
Sarah McDonnell-Davies then responded to questions from the Committee:
Cllr Cohen proposed that the Committee should formally support the recommendations made by the deputation. This position was approved by the Committee. Cllr Clarke proposed that the Committee submit this in writing to the ICB with a response provided to the next JHOSC meeting in March 2024.
The main recommendation of the deputation was that:
“ICBs must conduct a full and widely publicised consultation on the proposed sale so the public, patient and carers can participate meaningfully in the decision making.”
The deputation also proposed an alternative approach:
The alternatives that ICBs and their Primary Care Committees could adopt would secure a safer, more stable service and better value for money:
RESOLVED –
a) The Committee recommended that NCL ICB should conduct a full and widely publicised consultation on the proposed sale of GP practices to HCRG Care Group so the public, patient and carers could participate meaningfully in the decision making.
b) The Committee also endorsed the alternative approach proposed by the deputation as described above.