Agenda and minutes

Scrutiny Review - Men's Health: Getting to the heart of the matter
Monday, 17th October, 2011 6.30 pm

Items
No. Item

1.

Apologies for absence

Minutes:

Dr Fiona Wright, AD Public Health

2.

Urgent Business

The Chair will consider the admission of any late items of urgent business.  (Late items will be considered under the agenda item which they appear.  New items will be dealt with at item 10 below).

Minutes:

None

3.

Declarations of Interest

A member with a personal interest in a matter who attends a meeting of the authority at which the matter is being considered must disclose to that meeting the existence and nature of that interest at the commencement of that consideration, or when the interest becomes apparent.

A member with a personal interest in a matter also has a prejudicial interest in that matter if the interest is one which a member of the public with knowledge of the relevant facts would reasonably regard as so significant that it is likely to prejudice the member’s judgement of the public interest and i9if this interest affects their financial position or the financial of a person or body as described in paragraph 8 of the Code of Conduct and/or it is related to the determining of any approval, consent, license, permission or registration in relation to them or any person or body described in paragraph 8 of the Code of Conduct.

Minutes:

Dr Rebecca Viney – Member of the Health and Wellbeing Board Executive and Clinical Commissioning Group.

 

4.

Tottenham Foundation

To hear from Maria Abraham, Health and Wellbeing Manager, Tottenham Foundation on working with men to improve their health and wellbeing and an update on the Health Check Programme bid.

Minutes:

 

Maria Abraham, Health and Wellbeing Manager

 

An update on the Premier League bud to fund a Health Check programme was given.

 

Please see attached presentation.

 

Key points from the discussion:

 

Funding would be from Premier League and Public Health match funded.

 

Target group would not necessarily go to Tottenham stadium as they would find it daunting and they also do not have the funds to pay for matches.

 

To access the target group do not attend on match days – this is not the target group.

 

A good point of access would be Tottenham Community Sports Centre on Thursday mornings when there is a market.

  • Centre would be a good venue for health checks

 

Programme would aim to cover as many languages as possible when recruiting Health Ambassadors from the local community.  The role of the Health Ambassadors would be to spread health messages and encourage men to uptake health checks in the programme.

 

Other good places to raise awareness would be:

  • Community parks
  • Lordship Recreation Ground and café
  • Downhills
  • Caribbean cafes and takeaways
  • Barber shops

 

Cultural aspects e.g. Turkish Community are highly likely to be smokers.

 

Target of the programme is 3000 health checks over the course of the project. 

 

Programme would target the men who are unlikely to attend GP surgeries and who are less likely to engage with health services.

 

Noted that the programme will not be widely advertised due to budget constraints.

 

Discussion around forums for advertising the programme which would not necessarily cost e.g. mosque newsletters.

 

Health Trainers would be assisting on days when Health Checks are taking place.  Their role would include signposting people to other services as well as the services which their provide themselves.

 

Noted that men do visit pharmacies for a variety of reasons including to self medicate, buying other items and for general information.

 

Discussion around whether pharmacies would be able to refer men onto the Tottenham Hotspur Foundation programme if they do not provide health checks themselves or where a person is unable to pay for one being offered in  a pharmacy.

 

John Nunney would be happy to be a link into pharmacies for this piece of work.

 

Discussion around how information could be given to pharmacies – suggested that Health Ambassadors would be able to help in their communities.

 

Should funding be confirmed the programme would start in early March 2012.

 

Health checks would be done by the British Heart Foundation. 

 

Maria would be looking at getting the health checks done at a variety of times and not always within 9-5 e.g. early morning or after work hours.

 

Discussion around the use of schools as an outlet for information e.g. school newsletters.  Noted that children can be a very good route of getting messages and information to their families.

 

Discussion about a ‘Bring your dad’ session where children are offered a chance to see the Spurs ground and their dads would then be given a health check.

 

Noted that when health checks are offered in the right setting  ...  view the full minutes text for item 4.

5.

Dr Rebecca Viney

To hear from Dr Rebecca Viney, Shadow Clinical Commissioning Group board member & Coaching and Mentoring Lead, London Deanery.

 

Minutes:

Discussion around how well informed GP Surgeries are in terms of the local population e.g. do all GPs and their practice staff know the context in which they are working e.g. the life expectancy gap?

 

Noted that the Clinical Commissioning Group is considering have a ‘Haringey Health’ website which would not be about ill health but about health and prevention.

 

Noted that some countries are better than the UK at social marketing of health messages. 

 

There are a number of diseased that people do not know the symptoms for e.g. bowel cancer.

 

Noted that employers should encourage men to go for health checks.

 

Noted that men, and in particular some ethnic groups, do not want to see or be seen by women.  There is a tension here as it is generally women who are in these positions.

 

Discussion around whether GP surgeries could do men’s hours or session.  Noted that there would be Equalities Act legislation around this which would make it difficult e.g. could be seen as positive discrimination.

 

Dr Viney would be happy to assist with a recommendation around men and health checks.

 

Noted that it does not have to be a GP who does the health checks.

 

Noted that libraries are a good point of contact for the target group.

 

Discussion around the big opportunity to get pharmacies involved.

Noted that pharmacies can refer to a GP when they do health checks – some have a question about whether the person is happy for their information/results to be sent to their GP after. 

  • If the person is not registered with a GP the Pharmacist will give them a list of local GPs.
  • Discussion around how you can actually get men to then go to their/a GP.

 

Discussion around the fact that not everyone knows their way around the UK health system and not everyone knows that it is free.

  • Need to think of ways to help people to navigate the health system.

 

Discussion around who attends A&E rather than going to their GP or another health professional.

  • What are the demographics of attendees?
  • Do they have GPs?
  • Age? Ethnicity?

 

Could A&E be used as a place to disseminate information?

 

Discussion around the use of role models – suggestions Spurs players e.g. Benoît Assou-Ekotto

 

Noted that awareness raising in the community is key.

 

 

6.

Public Health

To hear from a Public Health representative on the work being undertaken to tackle health inequalities specifically relating to men’s health and cardiovascular disease.

Minutes:

Derferred

7.

NHS Haringey AGM feedback pdf icon PDF 84 KB

To note the feedback from local men and local health representatives from the NHS Haringey AGM and discuss any next steps arising from the feedback.

 

  • How do we get men to go to health services when they have early symptoms?
  • What is it that prevents them from going early enough?
  • How can we encourage men to keep themselves well?

Minutes:

Noted

8.

Dates of future meetings

Thursday 17th November, 6.30-8.30

Thursday 8th December, 5.30-7.30

Minutes:

17th November, 6.30-8.30

8th December, 5.30-7.30

 

9.

Minutes pdf icon PDF 114 KB

To approve the minutes of the meeting held on 19th September 2011.

Additional documents:

Minutes:

Approved

10.

New items of urgent business

To consider any items submitted under Item 2 above.

Minutes:

None