Decision details

Bruce Castle Museum Phase 2 - Permission to initiate tender action for a Construction Works Contract.

Decision Maker: Cabinet

Decision status: Recommendations Approved

Is Key decision?: No

Is subject to call in?: No

Decision:

DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST MADE FOR FOR THIS ITEM:

 

None

 

RESOLVED:

 

That Cabinet:

 

1.    Pursuant to Contract Standing Order 2.01(b), approve the commencement of a tendering process for the appointment of a construction works contractor to deliver the Phase 2 works at Bruce Castle Museum.

 

Reasons for the Decision

 

It was considered necessary to appoint a construction works contractor to undertake the refurbishment works in order to safeguard the historic and cultural significance of Bruce Castle Museum, a Grade I listed building. The works were also required to protect the Council's archive and local history collections held within the museum and to address identified building condition issues.

 

The contractor was intended to be selected through a competitive single-stage tender process. The London Construction Programme General Framework had been considered but was not considered suitable, as the appointed contractors did not have sufficient experience in the delivery of heritage building projects. At the time of the report, a Dynamic Purchasing System (DPS) was the preferred procurement route. It was proposed that the works be delivered under a JCT Standard Building Contract.

 

Soft market testing was to continue in order to confirm the suitability of the proposed contract form, establish an appropriate programme duration, and assess market interest and contractor availability.

 

Alternative Options Considered

 

Do Nothing

The option of not progressing the procurement was considered but not pursued. Ongoing water ingress through the roof, together with identified safety and compliance issues, meant that delaying or avoiding the works would have increased reactive maintenance costs and heightened risks to visitors, staff, and museum collections.

 

In-House Delivery

Delivery of the works using internal Council resources was considered but not pursued. The Council did not have the capacity, specialist expertise, or qualifications required to undertake the refurbishment works, particularly given the complexity of working on a Grade I listed heritage asset.

 

Open Tender Through Contracts Finder

The option of undertaking an unrestricted tender exercise through Contracts Finder was considered. However, this approach was expected to result in a longer procurement process and would likely have delayed the commencement and delivery of the project.

 

Use of an Alternative Public Sector Dynamic Purchasing System

The use of an alternative public sector Dynamic Purchasing System was considered but not pursued. It was concluded that this approach would not have complied with the relevant Contract Standing Orders, and therefore was not considered the preferred procurement route.

 

Publication date: 10/11/2026

Date of decision: 10/11/2026

Decided at meeting: 10/11/2026 - Cabinet

Accompanying Documents: